-
British Clergyman Repudiates The ...
Contributed by Sermon Central on Jun 6, 2010 (message contributor)
British Clergyman Repudiates the Church’s Traditional Understanding of the Cross
The Very Reverend Dr. Jeffrey Philip Hywel John believes that the church’s traditional understanding of the cross of Christ is both “repulsive” and “insane.” His comments in the spring of 2007 about the cross ignited a firestorm in Great Britain that eventually spread to the United States.
This is what The Telegraph [London] said about the controversy before his message was broadcast on the BBC:
The Very Rev. Jeffrey John, who had to withdraw before taking up an appointment as bishop of Reading in 2003 after it emerged he was in a long-term homosexual relationship, is set to ignite a row over one of the most fundamental tenets of Christian belief.
Clergy who preach this Easter that Christ was sent to earth to die in atonement for the sins of mankind are “making God sound like a psychopath,” he will say.
Very Reverend Dr. Jeffrey John is not being misquoted. He describes what he was taught as a child:
The explanation I was given went something like this. God was very angry with us for our sins, and because he is a just God, our sin had to be punished. But instead of punishing us he sent his Son, Jesus, as a substitute to suffer and die in our place. The blood of Jesus paid the price of our sins, and because of him God stopped being angry with us. In other words, Jesus took the rap, and we got forgiven, provided we said we believed in him.
In other words, he was taught a biblical understanding of the cross and its significance. He calls that understanding of the cross “insane.” He said:
Well, I don’t know about you, but even at the age of ten I thought this explanation was pretty repulsive as well as nonsensical. What sort of God was this, getting so angry with the world and the people he created, and then, to calm himself down, demanding the blood of his own Son? And anyway, why should God forgive us through punishing somebody else? It was worse than illogical, it was insane. It made God sound like a psychopath. If any human being behaved like this we’d say they were a monster. (AlbertMohler.com)
What this man does is reject the idea Jesus died on the cross as a substitutionary sacrifice, and he invents a meaning for the cross that is more in line with his prejudices. Paul taught in Romans 3 that holy God has every right to demand an acceptable sacrifice in order to satisfy His justifiable wrath against sin, but as a demonstration of love He also provided that same sacrifice.
This preacher not only disagrees with Paul, he disagrees with Jesus. This is the understanding he gave to his disciples before he died for sinners. This is what Peter preached at Pentecost. It is the entire message of Hebrews.
From a sermon by Ed Sasnett, Nothing to Add, 6/2/2010
Related Sermon Illustrations
-
According To The National Highway Traffic Safety ...
Contributed by Bruce Willis on Jan 5, 2007
According to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration 6,390 young people ages 15-20 died in motor vehicle crashes in the year 2,000? Of them alcohol was involved in 2,339 deaths. And as related to drivers – 3,594 young drivers ages 15-20 died in motor vehicle crashes in 2,000 and of ...read more
-
Perhaps You've Heard Of Watchman Nee. Watchman ... PRO
Contributed by Karl Eckhoff on Nov 13, 2003
Perhaps you’ve heard of Watchman Nee. Watchman Nee became a Christian in mainland China in 1920 at the age of seventeen and began writing in the same year. Throughout the nearly thirty years of his ministry, Watchman Nee was a unique gift from the Lord to the church. Though imprisoned for his ...read more
-
A 2 A.m. Miracle – Joni Eareckson Tada
Contributed by Greg Buchner on Oct 11, 2004
“A 2 a.m. Miracle” – Joni Eareckson Tada It was 2 a.m. and Ken, my husband was snoring softly beside me, not aware that I was biting my lip to keep from waking him up. The combination of my paralysis with middle-of-the-night insomnia always makes me feel claustrophobic. But this was different. ...read more
-
The Story Is Told Of A Teacher Tells About ... PRO
Contributed by Timothy Smith on Aug 2, 2004
The story is told of a teacher tells about taking a 2nd grader to the library to help her learn to read. The book she choose for the girl only had pictures. So the teacher sat down with the child and said, "Why don’t you identify the pictures for me?" She started: "That’s a house, that’s a man, ...read more
-
Asking Amiss. Two Boys Were On The Freshman ... PRO
Contributed by Ed Wood on Jul 1, 2004
ASKING AMISS. Two boys were on the freshman debating team in college. The big night of their first debate, they nervously paced up and down their practice room offstage. The debating coach stuck his head in the door to remind them that the debate was only fifteen minutes away. Ages later he said it ...read more
Related Sermons
-
What Jesus Touches, He Changes. Series
Contributed by Jeff Strite on Apr 24, 2016
His name had been Saul, but that - along with his entire life - was changed when he met Jesus. What changed him and what can we learn from his experience?
-
A Wild Life Series
Contributed by Jeff Strite on Aug 25, 2013
Jesus saved us to live a wild and adventurous life. But how can we do that? We're not apostles like Peter and John were. We don't have their courage and experience. We're just common ordinary folks... or are we?
-
God's Illogical Demand Series
Contributed by Jeff Strite on Mar 13, 2016
I thought God hated child sacrifice? What is God doing asking Abraham to sacrifice his only son?
-
Which Cross Is Yours
Contributed by Dr. Jerry N. Watts on Dec 6, 2016
To preach this message, I showed the "Three Crosses of Golgotha" and named each cross. The title of the message became the altar call.
-
The Centurion At The Feet Of Jesus Series
Contributed by Jeff Strite on Mar 11, 2018
The story of this Centurion is listed in 3 of the Gospels because God wants us to see what he saw. What did the centurion see that day, and why did he cry out "Surely this was the Son of God"?