Religious Play-Acting
The Sermon on the Mount opens with blessing and ends with a choice: sand or rock, appearance or obedience.
Between those two poles, Matthew 6 sits like a quiet heart—Jesus’ exposition of motive. Here the Lord shifts from what disciples do to why they do it. He moves from behavior to intention, from outer ritual to inner reality.
The setting matters. Jesus had just spoken of righteousness that must exceed that of the scribes and Pharisees (Matthew 5:20). To His listeners, that sounded impossible.
The Pharisees were the professional righteous. They had turned devotion into a public performance with measurable success—fasting schedules, tithing ledgers, prayer times, visible badges of holiness. In first-century Galilee, spirituality was theater.
The Greek word Matthew chooses for “to be seen” in Matthew 6:1 is theathenai—from which we get our word theater. Jesus could not have chosen a sharper image.
He was describing an age of religious acting—people doing sacred things for audience approval. The same disease thrives in us. We move through stages, microphones, screens, likes, metrics, applause. The Lord’s warning pierces centuries of progress and lands squarely in our digital age.
> “Take heed that you do not your alms before men, to be seen of them; otherwise you have no reward of your Father which is in heaven.” (Matthew 6:1)
That verse is the thesis of the entire chapter. From it flow three illustrations—giving, praying, fasting. Each is not merely a discipline but a mirror; each reveals what drives the heart. And each is introduced by a presumption of practice: When you give, when you pray, when you fast. Jesus assumes devotion; He questions motivation. His concern is not that piety exists but that it breathes.
>>The hidden Father
Throughout the passage, one phrase repeats like a heartbeat: “Your Father who sees in secret.” Six times Jesus names the Father in these verses. The point is not secrecy for secrecy’s sake; it’s relationship. The Father is the unseen audience of genuine worship. To live before Him is the essence of holiness. Hebrews 4:13 says, “All things are naked and opened unto the eyes of Him with whom we have to do.” The unseen life is the true life.
To the Pharisee, the world was full of observers—neighbors, fellow rabbis, reputation. To the disciple, the world is full of One: the Father who sees. He is not hidden because He is distant but because intimacy always hides itself from spectacle. Lovers whisper, they do not shout. Prayer, giving, fasting—these are love songs, not auditions.
When Jesus said, “Enter into your closet” (Matthew 6:6), the Greek tamieion meant a storeroom, the innermost room of a house without windows. It is the same word used for the secret chamber where treasures were kept. Jesus was saying, “Meet your Father where treasures are hidden.” The soul’s wealth grows in that dark room.
>>The reward language
Another recurring word is reward—Greek misthos, meaning wages, payment. The irony is deliberate. Those who perform for applause receive their wage immediately—public approval. But the spiritual economy of heaven runs on different currency. God’s reward is never applause but transformation. He pays in peace, depth, and likeness to Himself.
The contrast is total: public religion ends in exhaustion; secret worship ends in rest. Jesus is not condemning visibility; He is condemning vanity. Deeds seen by others can still honor God—if the intention is revelation, not exhibition. “Let your light so shine before men” (Matthew 5:16) is not contradiction but completion. The same light that must shine must also come from a lamp tended in private.
>>The anatomy of hypocrisy
The Greek hypokrites originally meant an actor who wore a mask. Over time it came to mean anyone pretending to virtue. Jesus’ use of the term is not insult but diagnosis. The disease of hypocrisy begins whenever devotion loses dialogue and becomes display. The heart starts asking, How do I look? instead of Whom do I love?
The human soul was created for God’s gaze alone. The moment another audience enters, tension fractures the spirit. One eye on heaven, one on the crowd—sooner or later the pupils split. The Pharisee’s tragedy was not that he prayed or fasted, but that he no longer knew to whom he was praying or why he was fasting.
Behind every act of hypocrisy lies fear—the fear that grace is not enough, that we must supplement it with performance. So we decorate faith. Yet every addition subtracts. The more polish, the less power. Jesus strips the surface so the substance can breathe again.
>>The theology of giving
The first example Jesus chooses is giving. Charity (alms, eleemosyne) was central to Jewish piety. It reflected God’s own mercy (eleos). But by the first century it had become a badge of honor. Trumpets literally sounded in temple courts when major donors approached the treasury boxes. The clang of coins against brass echoed through the marble halls. The spectacle proved generosity. Jesus calls it theater: “Do not sound a trumpet before you, as the hypocrites do.”
He does not abolish generosity; He re-centers it. True giving is not transaction but imitation. The Father gives secretly—sunlight on evil and good alike, rain on the just and unjust (Matthew 5:45). When we give in secret, we resemble Him. The act trains the heart toward anonymity, the language of grace.
Paul echoes this theology: “God loves a cheerful giver” (2 Corinthians 9:7).
The word cheerful, hilaron, gives us “hilarious.” It means unrestrained, spontaneous, uncalculating. In hidden giving, the soul laughs like God—because nothing is being lost; everything is being returned.
>>The theology of prayer
After giving, Jesus turns to prayer. The contrast sharpens.
> “When you pray, you shall not be as the hypocrites are.” (Matthew 6:5)
To the Pharisee, prayer had become performance: posture, tone, and timing. Some prayed at street corners so that no one could miss their devotion. Yet the essence of prayer is presence, not presentation.
Jesus points His listeners back to relationship. When you pray, “enter your closet,” the tamieion again—the inner chamber. In Hebrew thought, prayer was always personal encounter: Abraham speaking with God under the oaks, Moses face-to-face in the tent, Hannah whispering at Shiloh. These weren’t ceremonies; they were conversations.
When Jesus tells His disciples to “shut the door,” He reclaims that lineage. The door closes not because God hides, but because intimacy can’t breathe in public air. The heart must first hear its own silence before it can hear the Father’s whisper.
The world applauds eloquence; heaven attends honesty. “Your Father knows what things you have need of, before you ask Him.” (Matthew 6:8) That sentence destroys manipulation. Prayer is not informing the uninformed; it is aligning the unformed.
The Lord then gives a pattern, not a recital—the prayer we call The Lord’s Prayer (Matthew 6:9–13). It is a theology in miniature:
Our Father — identity restored. The plural rescues us from isolation. We are never only “I” in God’s presence; we are “we.”
Which art in heaven — transcendence re-acknowledged; He is near yet above.
Hallowed be Thy name — worship precedes request; adoration purifies intention.
Thy kingdom come — the surrender of sovereignty; the abdication of self-rule.
Thy will be done on earth as it is in heaven — discipleship as imitation of celestial obedience.
Give us this day our daily bread — dependence, one sunrise at a time. The Greek epiousion implies “for the coming day”—each dawn, fresh manna.
Forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors — grace received becomes grace released; mercy refuses stagnation.
Lead us not into temptation, but deliver us from evil — awareness of frailty guarded by trust in providence.
Every phrase dismantles ego. This prayer, prayed slowly, strips the varnish of performance until what remains is relationship. It is not the many words but the real ones that reach heaven.
The Lord ends the section with forgiveness. He ties divine mercy to human posture: “If you forgive men their trespasses, your heavenly Father will also forgive you.” (Matthew 6:14) The play-actor’s heart cannot forgive; it’s too invested in image. True forgiveness requires remembering the backstage view—our own need for grace.
>>The theology of fasting
Next Jesus speaks of fasting. Again He assumes the practice: When you fast. Fasting, in Scripture, is never punishment of the body but pursuit of God. In the Hebrew prophets, especially Isaiah 58, God rebuked empty abstinence and called for justice instead of show: “Is not this the fast that I have chosen… to loose the bands of wickedness?” (Isaiah 58:6).
By the first century, fasting twice a week had become a social badge. Pharisees whitened their faces with ash so people would notice their sacrifice. Jesus reverses the script:
> “Anoint your head and wash your face.” (Matthew 6:17)
In other words—look alive. The act of anointing was festive. He’s saying, Let joy be your disguise. True fasting hides itself because it’s feasting on God.
Fasting is the physical translation of humility. It reminds the flesh who is master. But like every discipline, its meaning depends on motive. Without love, fasting is hunger strike; without secrecy, it is performance. Jesus transforms it into intimacy: a secret hunger met by a secret satisfaction—“Your Father, who sees in secret, will reward you.” (Matthew 6:18)
The pattern is complete now—three devotions, one motive. Each command points back to relationship. The emphasis is not secrecy but sincerity. The unseen life with the Father is the only soil where righteousness can grow.
>>The Father who sees
This phrase is the key that unlocks the whole passage: Your Father who sees in secret. God’s seeing is not surveillance; it is shepherding. The Hebrew Scriptures sing of it: “You see me,” said Hagar, naming Him El Roi—the God who sees (Genesis 16:13). “You have searched me and known me,” prayed David (Psalm 139:1). The divine gaze is never detached; it is participatory love.
The Pharisee’s tragedy was that he acted before a blind audience—the crowd, which cannot reward. The disciple acts before the all-seeing Father, who rewards with Himself. Holiness is not performing for God but living with God.
Paul picks up the theme: “For do I now persuade men, or God? Or do I seek to please men? For if I yet pleased men, I should not be the servant of Christ.” (Galatians 1:10) To serve Christ is to accept obscurity. Only love makes that bearable.
>>The theology of reward
The word “reward” reappears seven times in Matthew 6. Jesus is teaching that motives reveal what we value most. The actor values the crowd; the disciple values the Father. The crowd can give recognition but not regeneration. The Father offers transformation but often in secret.
This tension—between visibility and reality—runs through all of Scripture. Samuel stood before Jesse’s sons and heard God say, “Man looks on the outward appearance, but the Lord looks on the heart.” (1 Samuel 16:7) God’s gaze is discerning, not decorative. He rewards the hidden because He Himself is hidden—mystery dwelling in light unapproachable.
The ultimate reward of the secret life is the Father’s likeness. As Paul writes, “We all… beholding as in a glass the glory of the Lord, are changed into the same image.” (2 Corinthians 3:18). The verb “beholding” can mean “reflecting.” The soul becomes what it worships. That is the open reward—transformation, not trophies.
The righteous acts of Matthew 6 are not ways to earn salvation; they are ways grace expresses itself. Salvation is by faith; secrecy is by love. We hide our obedience not to gain credit but to guard intimacy.
>>The danger of divided motives
Jesus’ teaching moves from public piety to private loyalty. Immediately after the fasting section, He says, “Lay not up for yourselves treasures upon earth” (Matthew 6:19). The connection is deliberate: when devotion becomes public currency, even heaven becomes commerce. We begin to “store up” religious capital—reputation, status, influence. But treasure has gravity; it drags the heart wherever it lies. “For where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.” (Matthew 6:21)
Theology and motive converge here. Worship is not what we adore for an hour; it is where we invest affection day by day. Hypocrisy worships approval; discipleship worships the Father’s pleasure.
Paul describes this inner migration beautifully: “Our life is hid with Christ in God.” (Colossians 3:3) The hidden life is the safest life because no applause can corrupt it. When Christ is your hiding place, exposure no longer terrifies you.
>>The heart of secrecy
Secrecy in the kingdom is not concealment but communion. God hides the sacred not to hoard it but to invite pursuit. Proverbs 25:2 says, “It is the glory of God to conceal a matter; it is the honor of kings to search it out.” When you step into the secret place, you are answering that royal invitation.
The act of shutting the door is sacramental: the body enacts the soul’s withdrawal from vanity. Each time we pray unseen, give unnoticed, fast unannounced, the ego dies a little—and resurrection power fills the vacancy. Only those who have died to applause can carry glory without pride.
>>The theology of the hidden life
Hiddenness is not retreat from the world; it is resistance to vanity. Jesus Himself lived thirty quiet years before a single public miracle. The Father called that obscurity “My beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.” (Matthew 3:17) Heaven applauded an unrecorded life. That is the theology of secrecy: God delights before the crowd ever arrives.
The hidden life forms the inner scaffolding of faith. Every visible ministry depends on invisible fellowship. The strength that stands before men is borrowed from hours alone with God. Elijah could face Carmel because he had first stood in the presence of the Lord (1 Kings 17:1).
Daniel could interpret dreams because he had learned to pray behind closed windows. Jesus could still storms because He had already stilled His own soul in the night watches.
Holiness is not produced by publicity but by proximity. The Spirit shapes us in silence, not spectacle. The furnace of solitude forges authenticity. When the world’s noise fades, we rediscover that God speaks most clearly in whisper. “Be still, and know that I am God.” (Psalm 46:10) Stillness is not inactivity; it is receptivity—soul unclenched, ready for grace.
>>The radiance of transformation
The paradox of secrecy is that it eventually shines. Moses returned from Sinai unaware that his face glowed (Exodus 34:29). He did not manufacture that radiance; it was residue from proximity. The same happens to every believer who abides in the secret place. Glory leaks through cracks of humility.
Paul describes it in 2 Corinthians 4:6: “For God, who commanded the light to shine out of darkness, has shined in our hearts.” The verb tense is ongoing—light keeps shining. The closer we live to the Source, the more naturally we reflect Him. True evangelism is not performance but presence. The saint becomes sermon. The quiet life, lived transparently before God, preaches louder than any stage.
Jesus said, “When your eye is single, your whole body shall be full of light.” (Matthew 6:22)
A “single eye” means undivided focus—one audience, one allegiance. When the gaze is pure, the life becomes luminous. The Father’s light travels through clean motives like sunlight through clear glass. That is why integrity and joy so often appear together; they share the same Source.
>>The theology of joy
Joy is the final proof of authenticity. Pretending exhausts; abiding rejoices. In Psalm 16:11 David says, “In Your presence is fullness of joy.” Not in applause, not in recognition—in presence.
The hypocrite lives from compliment to compliment, always hungry again; the disciple drinks from a spring that never runs dry. Secret communion creates public stability. The heart that hides in God cannot be easily shaken.
Jesus even links secrecy and joy in fasting: “Anoint your head and wash your face.” Joy is holiness’s native expression. Gloom never made anyone holy. The kingdom advances not by grim duty but by glad surrender. Holiness wears a smile because love has displaced fear.
>>The cross as the end of performance
The ultimate secret act was Calvary. Jesus performed the greatest work of redemption without applause, almost without witnesses who understood. Darkness covered the land, and yet heaven’s spotlight was fixed on the cross. There, the Actor became the sacrifice.
The One who had warned against play-acting died stripped of costume and reputation. His last words—“It is finished” (John 19:30)—ended every audition for righteousness.
At the cross, the masks fall. Humanity’s pretense meets divine honesty. God does not save the character we pretend to be; He saves the person hidden beneath. The gospel’s invitation is not “Improve your performance” but “Enter My rest.”
Hebrews 4:10 declares, “He who has entered His rest has also ceased from his own works.” Grace is the curtain’s close on self-effort and the dawn of real life.
>>Living from the secret place
How then shall we live? By practicing the presence of the Father in all things. Brother Lawrence called it “the ministry of turning the pan in love.” Every act—ordinary or sacred—can become prayer if done for the Father’s eyes alone. “Whatever you do, do it heartily, as to the Lord, and not to men.” (Colossians 3:23)
To live this way is to rediscover simplicity. Give because the Father gave. Pray because the Father listens. Fast because the Father satisfies. When devotion detaches from performance, peace becomes its reward. You begin to live without fear of exposure because there is nothing left to hide.
>>The open reward
Jesus promised that the Father who sees in secret will “reward you openly.” (Matthew 6:18) The reward is not wealth or status; it is revelation. God makes Himself known. “I will manifest Myself to him.” (John 14:21) The hidden life eventually overflows into visible compassion, courage, and credibility. The world may not understand the source, but it will feel the warmth.
This is what happened to the early church. They had no stages, no spotlights, few resources—but they had authenticity. Their meetings smelled of prayer, their generosity astonished pagans, their joy bewildered persecutors. The secret became public: Christ lived in them. That was the open reward.
>>The invitation
Perhaps you’ve been living under the weight of performance—checking metrics, guarding image, editing spirituality for consumption. The Father is calling you off the stage. He says, Come into the quiet. Shut the door. Let Me be enough. No audience, no scoreboard—just presence.
This is the gospel’s mercy: Jesus died so we could stop pretending.
The One who performed perfectly gives His perfection freely. All that remains is to receive. Let grace have the final word. Drop the script; take His hand. You are seen, known, and loved.
---
Prayer
Father, thank You for seeing through every mask and still loving us.
Teach us the joy of hidden obedience—the beauty of giving, praying, and fasting for Your eyes alone.
Deliver us from performance faith and draw us back to the secret place where Your love becomes the only applause we need.
Make us radiant from within, so that when the world sees us, they see You.
In Jesus’ name,
Amen.
