There are phrases that sound almost sacrilegious in a prayer meeting. Not curse words. Just sentences that don’t fit the script Christian culture hands us. And the moment they come out of your mouth, the atmosphere shifts. Forks freeze above plates. Eyes widen. Someone nearly inhales a dinner roll.
I dropped one of those lines once.
It wasn’t profanity. I didn’t renounce the Trinity.
All I said was: “I don’t think I can pray that for you.”
You would’ve thought I just told the group Jesus had retired.
My home group had just finished a meal together. Laughter. Shared dessert. People pulling up chairs and finding the comfortable rhythm that only comes when you’ve known each other long enough to show your mess. Prayer request time came around, which is where most groups transition from nachos to nervousness.
Kris shared her request with trembling frustration.
Her young adult daughter planned to move in with her boyfriend that weekend.
Kris wanted us to pray that God would stop it. Block it. Shut the whole thing down.
Her voice cracked.
Her pain was real.
Her fear was loud.
Most of us have been in Kris’s shoes. We see someone we love sprinting toward a cliff and we beg God to tackle them before they go over the edge.
No one could blame her desire.
The room nodded solemnly.
But something inside me knew that specific request wasn’t…
well…prayable.
So I gently tapped the brakes.
“Look,” I said, “I understand why you want that. We all do. If someone here feels that’s what God wants, you’re welcome to pray that way. But I’m concerned about us asking God to override someone’s ability to make moral choices.”
The table collectively held its breath.
The temperature rose ten degrees.
I pushed a little further:
“Isn’t that dangerously close to witchcraft? Trying to make someone behave how we want instead of surrendering them to God’s love?”
There was a flicker in Kris’s eyes.
Offense. Hurt. Maybe a touch of “I can’t believe this guy.”
I leaned in and softened my tone.
“What if instead of praying for God to change her daughter, we pray for God to walk closely with Kris through whatever comes? That He would reveal Himself to her daughter in love. And that Kris could trust God even if her daughter makes the stupidest mistake of her young life.”
Tears. Silent at first.
Then heartbreak poured out of her like a dam breaking.
“That’s exactly what I need.”
We gathered around her.
And instead of praying for her daughter’s behavior,
we prayed for Kris’s heart.
And a shallow prayer meeting turned into
a holy moment of transformation.
Because that’s what real prayer does.
It changes someone.
And spoiler alert: usually the first someone God changes…is us.
---
>> The Genie Prayer Problem
Somewhere along the way, the church started treating prayer like we’re talking to a divine customer service rep. You submit your request. God issues a tracking number. Then you refresh the spiritual shipping page to see if the miracle has left the warehouse.
We act like if we throw enough requests at heaven, one is bound to stick eventually.
In many churches, here’s the weekly ritual:
Collect a list of requests
Speed-pray through them
Hope that covers it
No questions.
No discernment.
No follow-up.
No expectation.
Just a polite spiritual exercise before dessert.
Even kids can smell the disconnect.
One morning my son interrupted our devotional on John 15. We had just read verse 7:
“If you remain in me and my words remain in you, ask whatever you wish and it will be done for you.”
He looked up and said:
“That’s not true.”
Not rebellion.
Not cynicism.
Just observation.
He had noticed that most things we prayed for…never happened.
The dissonance was loud.
And he wasn’t going to pretend it wasn’t.
Kids are brilliant like that.
They hold us accountable to the actual outcomes we’re modeling.
If all they witness are unanswered balloons of prayer floating into the void, they conclude either:
A) God doesn’t care
B) God doesn’t listen
C) Prayer is a game adults play to feel better
And with each trivial request—
“Make my sniffles disappear.”
“Keep the rain away from the church picnic.”
—our theology shrinks until prayer becomes a Christian version of a birthday wish.
We would never say this out loud, but the message beneath these prayers is unmistakable:
“God exists to improve our comfort.”
Except He doesn’t.
And when we pray like He does, we are discipling people into disappointment.
---
>> Prayers God Never Promised To Answer
Let’s name a few unhelpful patterns:
>> 1) The Trivial
Praying the weather away.
Praying colds to be gone by Tuesday.
Is God too small for these things? No.
But prayer is too big for these things.
God isn’t our climate control system.
>> 2) The Self-Motivated
“Don’t let my brother deploy to Kuwait.”
“Stop anything risky or inconvenient.”
We want protection without purpose.
We want safety without sacrifice.
We want a discipleship that never costs us anything.
Yet Scripture insists:
faith grows where comfort dies.
>> 3) The Controlling
Like Kris’s request.
“If God could just force this person to behave…”
That’s not Christianity.
That’s puppetry.
God refuses to violate the freedom He gave us.
Why would He let us violate it?
>> 4) The Manipulative
Sometimes our prayers are aimed at humans, not God.
Like the four-year-old kid who prayed:
“Jesus, help Bob and Laurie learn to spank their children
so their kids won’t hit me anymore.”
She wasn’t praying.
She was politicking.
We get more subtle with age.
But our motives don’t always mature.
>> 5) The Blaming
“Well, she’s not pregnant because her husband isn’t godly enough.”
Is God waiting for perfection before giving gifts?
Then none of us would ever have children, or blessings, or grace.
Every answered prayer is a miracle through unworthy hands.
>> 6) The Mass-Produced
As if the number of pray-ers increases the probability of miracles.
“Send this to 10 friends so God will heal Bill’s toe.”
We treat prayer like a petition drive.
Signatures equal success.
Yet Jesus said:
“Where two or three gather…there I am.” (Matthew 18:20)
Not two hundred.
Not two thousand.
Just two or three hearts fully engaged.
Prayer is never about attendance numbers.
It’s about relational alignment.
---
>> Prayer Is Not Transaction. It’s Transformation.
Let’s be honest.
We prefer transaction over transformation.
Transaction keeps prayer predictable:
• I ask
• God delivers
Transformation requires surrender:
• I ask
• God changes me
• Everything looks different
One is a vending machine.
The other is a potter’s wheel.
Philippians 4:6 says: “Make your requests known to God.”
But it never says: “Expect God to obey.”
The purpose of prayer is not to twist God’s arm.
It is to place our hearts into His hands.
When we stop telling God what to do
and start listening for what He is doing,
prayer stops being a spiritual chore
and starts becoming a sacred adventure.
---
>> 5 Shifts Toward Praying With God Instead of At God
>> Shift 1: Focus on People, Not Problems
We default to event-focused prayers:
• Fix this situation
• Stop this event
• Avoid this outcome
But God cares far more about the person than the event.
The soldier being deployed?
Pray for courage, faith, and presence of God in hardship.
The mother afraid for her daughter?
Pray for trust and love that doesn’t fracture.
Events rise and fall.
People last forever.
Prayer is not an escape hatch from reality.
It is an invitation into someone’s soul.
That’s why smaller circles help.
Two or three who know the story.
Two or three who listen and love deeply.
Two or three who pray through tears rather than through clichés.
Because prayer is not a line item.
It’s relationship.
---
>> Shift 2: Seek God’s Perspective
We usually pray from:
• Our fears
• Our preferences
• Our best guess at the solution
Yet Scripture’s greatest prayers were prayed by people who refused to choose the easy option.
In Acts 4, the early believers were threatened:
“Stop preaching Jesus or else.”
They gathered to pray.
They didn’t ask God to remove the enemies.
They didn’t ask for an easier mission.
They prayed:
“Give us boldness.”
“Make us brave.”
“Help us obey even if it hurts.”
They wanted God’s heart more than God’s help.
Henry Blackaby taught believers to look for God’s activity first.
To pray from revelation, not assumption.
To say:
“God, what are You doing…and how can we join You?”
Prayer becomes powerful when we stop guessing
and start listening.
---
>> Shift 3: Let Trust, Not Fear, Fuel Your Prayers
Most default prayers come from panic.
“Oh no…fix this…make it go away…fast.”
Fear is loud.
Fear is bossy.
Fear wants God to reinforce our comfort.
But fear-based prayer secretly believes:
“If God doesn’t do what I ask, I can’t survive.”
And yet…our survival has never depended on answered requests.
It depends on the faithfulness of God.
Honestly, much of my prayer life growing up was simply me trying to manage anxiety. Even when nothing was wrong yet. Especially finances. Even when God had provided again and again, the future still spooked me.
I wasn’t asking God to deepen my trust.
I was asking Him to reduce the need for trust.
“Lord, bless this situation so thoroughly that I won’t have to rely on You.”
God loves giving good gifts.
But He refuses to answer prayers that would train us to trust Him less.
Fear says:
“I need God to reshape this circumstance.”
Faith says:
“I need God to reshape me.”
John writes with simple clarity:
“There is no fear in love; perfect love drives out fear.” (1 John 4:18)
We don’t pray to escape fear.
We pray until trust becomes louder.
So when fear grabs the mic, the prayer might sound like:
“Lord, help me trust You with whatever comes next. Reveal Your love until I feel it.”
When trust is strengthened, even the unanswered prayers feel safe.
---
>> Shift 4: Pray In Agreement
This one may feel unusual if you’ve never seen it practiced.
Most of the time, when someone is suffering, believers gather, lay hands, and declare a series of well-meaning solutions.
Fix them.
Heal them.
Make life better for them.
But what if that isn’t what God is doing…yet?
I once prayed with a group in the Australian bush. The leader began with strange instructions:
“We will only pray what we all agree on. If someone feels led to pray in a certain direction, we pause and make sure the person we’re praying for confirms they want that prayer.”
I asked: Why?
He said:
“We discovered we were unintentionally manipulating people. We’d pray they’d feel joy, and they felt obligated to smile afterward, even if their heart was breaking. We want permission-based prayer, not pressure-based prayer.”
That humbled me.
Agreement keeps prayer honest.
It keeps shame away.
It invites the Spirit to unify compassion and conviction.
When we pray in agreement:
• The person in need stays seen
• The Spirit sets the menu
• No one pretends to feel better just to satisfy the room
• We wait long enough to discern God’s direction
It protects prayer from becoming performance.
Agreement requires humility: “I want what God wants more than the prayer I came in ready to pray.”
That is spiritual maturity on display.
---
>> Shift 5: Follow Up
This one might be the missing ingredient in many churches.
We pray.
We say amen.
We go home.
Prayer becomes a moment, not a journey.
But if we truly believe God is working, shouldn’t we stay in the story?
Shouldn’t someone call Kris on Tuesday and ask:
“How is your heart today?
Is God helping you trust Him?”
Shouldn’t we ask the soldier’s family:
“Has courage grown since we prayed?”
Shouldn’t we say:
“What has God done since last week?
What did you notice?
How can we pray differently now?”
Follow-up communicates two things:
I care about you
I expect God to show up
Prayer is not a drive-thru.
It’s a discipleship pathway.
Philippians 4:6 tells us to present our requests to God…
But Philippians 4:7 promises what He gives in return:
“The peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, will guard your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus.”
Peace is not the result of God doing everything our way.
Peace is what God gives while He does things His way.
Follow-up helps us notice that.
---
>> Prayer That Disciples Us
Here’s the honest truth we avoid:
Prayer is dangerous.
It kills the illusion of control.
It exposes the motives behind our requests.
It invites faith where we prefer guarantees.
It dares love to be costly.
The goal of prayer is not:
• Easier lives
• Fewer problems
• More comfort
• Predictable outcomes
The goal of prayer is:
• Hearts aligned with Jesus
• Courage that outlives fear
• Love strong enough to hold relationships through disappointment
• Submission to God’s will even when it hurts
God cares about our circumstances.
He cares more about what those circumstances produce in us.
This is spiritual adulting.
This is Christian realism.
This is discipleship.
---
>> A Blessing That Sounds Like a Curse
One of Henri Nouwen’s spiritual directors once prayed over him:
“May all your expectations be frustrated.
May all your plans be thwarted.
May all your desires be withered into nothingness
that you may experience the powerlessness and poverty of a child
and sing and dance in the love of God the Father, the Son, and the Spirit.”
It sounds harsh…
until you realize the gift hidden in it:
A heart free from control
is a heart free to love.
This prayer dismantles idolatry.
It kills the god we make in our own image
so the living God can resurrect us into His.
This is prayer with teeth.
This is prayer with courage.
This is prayer that honors God’s sovereignty.
You don’t pray something like that over strangers.
But for those who trust you
and trust Jesus more…
it is the most loving prayer in the world.
---
>> Full Circle at the Kitchen Table
Remember Kris?
She didn’t get the prayer she wanted.
She got the prayer she needed.
Her daughter still made her decision.
There were tears.
There was hurt.
There were nights when Kris wondered if God cared.
But something happened in her…
She wasn’t alone.
She wasn’t trying to control anymore.
She was living like someone who believed God was involved even in the mess.
Control gave way to compassion.
Fear gave way to trust.
Anxiety gave way to peace that made no earthly sense.
We did follow up.
We stayed in the story.
We kept asking:
“How is God shaping you?”
“What’s He doing next?”
And she would say:
“Everything is different even though nothing has changed.”
That’s prayer.
Not magic.
Transformation.
---
>> Stop Telling God What To Do
Prayer was never meant to be:
• Wish lists
• Pressure campaigns
• Behavior modification for others
• A scoreboard for outcomes
Prayer was always meant to be:
• Alignment with the heart of God
• Partnership with Him in real time
• Formation of character
• Intimate trust regardless of results
If we never let God change our expectations,
we never learn who He really is.
So here’s the invitation, church…
Stop telling God what to do.
Start asking Him what He’s already doing.
Then join Him in that holy work.
---
>>A Simple Practice to Begin Today
Next time someone shares a request, ask:
“How is God inviting us to pray for you in this?”
Sit in the silence a moment.
Listen.
Discern.
Agree.
Then pray with expectancy,
not because you demand a result,
but because you trust the One you’re talking to.
And just maybe…through prayer…
• Your fear will loosen its grip
• Your joy will return
• Your love will stretch
• Your faith will grow up
• Your heart will fall deeper in sync with God’s
That’s not prayer as wishful thinking.
That’s prayer as participation in God’s Kingdom.
And that is a prayer worth praying.
Every day.
For the rest of your life.
